I want to start with this:
Please know this is 100% not true. No one hates Dmac. I would love to discuss the case with him. So thank you for being here & having a civil discussion : )
I am aware you, kmik & karis have a history, but no one is out to prove you wrong. Everyone acknowledges all you have done for the case but we still have questions. We all just want to be able to discuss the case openly and ask any questions we may have.
Which brings me to:
That's my problem, to me mostly everything in this case is just maybes. I'm just going to mention the things I remember off the top of my head from your posts for now.
• Maybe Phillip did have some knowledge, maybe he just completely made it all up.
• Maybe MMB didn't know Justin was spending the night at 28, maybe they did. To me if they knew he was there Fri pm I would think it would have at least been a possibility to them that he would be there Sat pm. I need to refresh myself with Marilyn's FBI interview. But we haven't actually listened to that recording either so its hard for us to form our own opinion. That's not the first time Marilyn referred to Justin as evil .
• Maybe Tina screamed. Maybe Sue screamed. Didn't one of Crim or Bradley's reports say the sreams that were heard were males?
• Maybe Marty & Sue were having an affair. Maybe they weren't. Why did no one else ever mention that? I haven't seen reports of people saying that in 81 and no one local said it on the forums. Kathy Beckley didn't just omit the fact that her friend rode them home, she went as far as to say she heard Donna William's rode them home. Where are the reports of the bartender telling PCSO any of this in 81? I recall the document you posted on FB which said 'last to see the boys alive' . But different people can interpret things differently. To me it reads like something she was telling people "I was the last to see the boys alive" & PCSO heard her claims from someone. Is there an actual report from an interview with her in 81?
• The files being "hidden by LE". Was it really hidden or in lost in the all the other leads & reports. Seems they were getting pulled in every direction and following those leads.
• I'm not saying Princess is a liar but I have never seen that exchange or a post from her stating exactly how the conversation went. I've always just heard DT said he & Marty were great friends and rode around in his squad car together. Was this a phone conversation? What else was said, what questions lead up to that. Ever any email correspondences between them? We do know from the tape you recently found that DT & Shanks were cruising around with a drunken Marty, but to me it seemed more like they were hoping he would spill some info, perhaps something Justin had told him, or incriminate himself, not hanging out as buddies.
• The lightbulb, so that bulb was never replaced in the 6 years since the Sharps moved in? I still have to look up the info I found. I agree she may have unscrewed it that night proving premed. But its circumstantial, any defense attorney could argue other reasons for it being there.
• Since we are on the topic of Sheila, 100% she was less than helpful in 1981 & while on the forums. She couldnt remember anything yet had a photographic memory during the cabin tour video. She is one person I can see all 3 boys covering for (Tina is the other person I can see them covering for). And why would Sheila threaten to sue Justin if he published his supposed book? I would have been praying he wrote that book, hoping he might actually say something helpful for once. Maybe she was trying to hide that she was an accomplice or maybe she was trying to keep some things about her family secret. I also remember her writing to every cold case/investigation type tv show she could think of and asking for people to help. She even received s reply or two. Why would she do this if she was involved?
• The old forums. Definitely a lot of questionable behavior there. Unfortunately, I never got to see all of it. I think Richard had deleted most of his posts before I ever got to see them. But I saw enough to know stories were being spun. I never believed Mama Meeks. She claimed to be best friends with the Sharps, claimed to be in Keddie that morning yet never stopped by to be there for the to be there for the kids that were "practically family" and then takes in the man she thought was responsible!?! I wish people would have questioned her more back then. My recollection of that time was Mama telling crazy stories (Marty burning shoes with PCSO right down the road, etc) then reminding Marilyn of crazy stories she had told them & Marilyn acting like she didn't know what the heck she was talking about (the bloody sack & hammer in the basement). Unbelievable stories from the people we were led to be closest to the Sharps. The mysterious Jim the ex.
• Alyssa. As far as I'm aware there is just that one entry of Alyssa seeing Dana. The new revelations of Dana & Sheila. We have talked about it before on this forum but I tend to believe Alyssa liked Johnny & Sheila liked Dana. Dont think Mrs. Seabolt would have approved of her daughter dating Johnny Sharp. Dana was her excuse to see Johnny. Sheila actually liked Dana but had to keep it quiet because of Richard. Which is why Richard didnt know Dana was at 28 that night.
All that is a bunch of nothing really. Just thoughts & questions I have.
Here are my real questions, if you wish to continue discussing the case with us.
The fingerprints. Are you willing to check your forum to see if there is an old report regarding the fingerprints? I recall something from years ago about all the fingerprints identified came back to family or people with reason to be in the house. I specifically remember it being related to the tv or tv stand.
According to Stoy's Evidence Report -
zodiackillerhoax1986.freeforums.net/thread/369/pcso-stoys-evidence-photographic-reportFingerprints were collected from the following locations:
• _ / _ Fingerprint on....(stretched out & ineligible)
• 38a / ZZ - Fingerprint on top of TV in living room
• 38b/ AAA - " " " " "
• 38c/ BBB - " " " " "
• 66 / YYY - 2' 10" x 1' 6" x 1/2" wall board of east wall living room by front door. Bloody fingerprint.
• 68 AA - Ash tray on floor in kitchen between stove & sink, fingerprint.
• 69 BB - Saw found on back porch floor. Print lifted by DOJ Vasos
• 87-91- Fingerprint taken from metal center(?) at phone booth outside resort
In the page above, why are those specific entries related to the TV crossed out on the report? Maybe because they identified who they belonged to, such as family & the Meeks, Phillip & Henry? We know they matched prints to Sheila & Doug Albin so they must have been trying to match these prints as well . And its possible they identified some prints. What about the other fingerprints on Stoy's report, have they been tested recently?
So who was th partial match on the car?
DNA. Here is my thing, cold cases are being solved everyday. There have been major advancements in technology. Are these items being tested? The blood evidence, fingerprints, familial dna, touch dna, etc. Sounds like they have DNA on Marilyn, Dee, Marty. Yet none of the evidence came back with their DNA? We just have Justin's on the tape (he claimed to have put a rag on sue's wound & been the one to cover her. Couldn't he have also removed some tape from sue?) And the minor female DNA on the electrical cords, Paco requested the name not be released (Tina?). MMB have already been named suspects publically, if any DNA matched them I cant see that info being held back. The blood typing evidence I've seen all came back as O (the Sharps) & B (Dana). We know Bo is listed as A type according to his military records. What about the hair found in Johnny's hands, is that still around for testing? I just find it hard to believe no physical evidence has been attributed to MMB or any outsider.
Again, no one is out to prove you wrong. We all just want this solved. Tomorrow will be 40 years : ( There has to be evidence that holds the key to solving this. Everything else is just maybes.