Post by karis on Jun 25, 2018 8:03:00 GMT -6
According to popular theories, this is the evidence against Martin Smartt.
1. Justin- being in the house (to keep boys quiet) and allowed to live (along with Ricky and Greg)
That could have been a reason to let Justin live but it does not explain Ricky or Greg. If your confident that Ricky and Greg will keep quiet why not have that same confidence in Tina?
2. Being in the bar that night
So was Joel Lipsey. He was later accused of child molesting
3. Walking by the house that night
Jan Albin and her husband also walked by that night around 11:30
4. Having Bo at his residence (a mafia man)
BO had only been in Keddie 2-3 weeks. Marty might have been confident the boys would remain silent but why would Bo? He didn't know these kids. Why did he have sympathy on these three.
5. The love letter
6. The confession to therapist
He was not the only person to confess to these murders
7. Student at QHS name him
Who was behind the gossip at the high school
8. The statement: "he's quiet enough to where he could have noticed something without me detecting him"
Seems to me to have been taken out of context
9: The hammer (one found in pond recently) "my hammer is missing"
How could Marty be sure they would not check to pond for HIS hammer
10: NEW EVIDENCE: having affair with Sue
That "vetted" information comes from the person who refused to tell the police she gave them a ride home but told them Sue was having an affair with Smartt
11: Friendship with Doug Thomas
Once again, how could Marty have been sure that his "friendship" (in in fact they were friends) with Doug would assure him protection.
12: Statement that he resembled composite
He was not the only one that was turned in as looking like the composites
Am I missing anything?