Post by Admin Horan on Apr 5, 2018 8:25:37 GMT -6
That's what I mean about this "report" being worthless. According to the autopsy reports:
Dana was punched in the face a couple of times and whacked on the ass with something like a broom handle (or barrel of a pellet gun) then some time later choked (not by hands; more likely, in a choke hold) then, some considerable time after death, hit several times around the head with a round-faced hammer. That's it.
Johnny's skull was severely fractured just above the left ear with something like a metal pipe or baseball bat etc, which probably would have been fatal within a few hours or less. Then, he was stabbed in the voicebox with a narrow, nonserrated blade (maybe a pocket knife or possibly a pair of scissors) then some little time later was stabbed in the carotid artery (it took two tries) with a narrow nonserrated blade (probably the same one) then, very soon after bleeding out, was hit around the head a few times with the same size round-faced hammer as Dana.
Sue was first battered around the head with what looks very much to have been the pellet gun (and a small round wound on her chest looks very much like she had been shot with the spent pellet that was found on the floor near the bodies. So, likely, she was shot, then battered) with corresponding defensive wounds on her hands and forearms. Then, she was tied up and gagged. Then, she was stabbed in the voicebox with probably the same narrow blade. Then, some minutes later, she was stabbed in the chest with a wide blade (apparently, the butcher knife) piercing her aorta, and she bled out. NO hammer wounds.
The other details, including various degrees of subdural hematoma, etc, indicate the following probable, rough chronology:
1. Dana was bound with the white tape, then worked over pretty good. Johnny was also bound with the white tape. Not very well, but they were bound.
2. Dana was put in a chokehold, probably sitting on a hard chair. He died as a result, but remained sitting in place, suggesting that maybe his assailant did not even realize he had died.
3. Johnny was struck forcefully with something like a baseball bat, possibly AFTER realizing that Dana was dead. Assuming his assailant was right-handed, that means he was struck by someone standing in front of him. It's theoretically possible he was hit by Dana, but Dana was most likely choked from BEHIND, so... Johnny very likely lost consciousness immediately.
4. Johnny was stabbed in the voicebox to make sure he couldn't scream.
5. Johnny and Dana were moved from wherever they were assaulted to more or less the places they were found. They were "tied together" with electric cord (NO phone cord was used at all.)
5. Johnny was placed on the floor with his head on a cushion and stabbed in the side of the neck twice in the same wound, piercing his carotid artery. He bled out.
6. Sue came out of the girls bedroom, walked through the puddle of Johnny's blood, was shot in the chest with the pellet gun, then was battered with it. Then she was tied up and gagged. Then she was stabbed in the voicebox. Then she was stabbed in the chest with the butcher knife. Then, Johnny and Dana were knocked in the head a few times (never the faces) with the hammer.
7. This all implies several things: There was no original intention to kill ANYBODY. Dana was killed accidentally; Johnny had to be neutralized; their assailants tried to make the whole thing look like some kind of home invasion; Sue surprised them; they had to silence Sue; some or all of them left the scene taking they narrow blade and the pellet gun with them; someone stayed behind and stabbed Sue with the butcher knife and hit the two boys around the head (rather half-heartedly; or, perhaps, they weren't very strong) and oddly enough, did NOT remove the butcher knife or hammer from the cabin. But they DID cover Sue with TWO blankets from the girls bedroom. Not the boys. Just Sue.
8. These facts, plus Justin's "statements," suggest two things: A. Justin did the work with the butcher knife and hammer, probably AFTER the other assailants had left Cabin 28; and B. Think about it. It's terribly, terribly simple. True? Maybe not. But terribly simple.
9. What does the physical evidence tell us about what happened to Tina? Absolutely nothing at all. But it does suggest TWO things: Tina left Cabin 28 alive, probably more or less voluntarily, some time--we have NO idea when--between 10:00pm and 8:15 am. And that SHE covered Sue's dead body with the blankets before she left.
10. Remember, there is NO evidence of ANY kind AT ALL that ANY "outsiders" came into Cabin 28 that night.
Dana was punched in the face a couple of times and whacked on the ass with something like a broom handle (or barrel of a pellet gun) then some time later choked (not by hands; more likely, in a choke hold) then, some considerable time after death, hit several times around the head with a round-faced hammer. That's it.
Johnny's skull was severely fractured just above the left ear with something like a metal pipe or baseball bat etc, which probably would have been fatal within a few hours or less. Then, he was stabbed in the voicebox with a narrow, nonserrated blade (maybe a pocket knife or possibly a pair of scissors) then some little time later was stabbed in the carotid artery (it took two tries) with a narrow nonserrated blade (probably the same one) then, very soon after bleeding out, was hit around the head a few times with the same size round-faced hammer as Dana.
Sue was first battered around the head with what looks very much to have been the pellet gun (and a small round wound on her chest looks very much like she had been shot with the spent pellet that was found on the floor near the bodies. So, likely, she was shot, then battered) with corresponding defensive wounds on her hands and forearms. Then, she was tied up and gagged. Then, she was stabbed in the voicebox with probably the same narrow blade. Then, some minutes later, she was stabbed in the chest with a wide blade (apparently, the butcher knife) piercing her aorta, and she bled out. NO hammer wounds.
The other details, including various degrees of subdural hematoma, etc, indicate the following probable, rough chronology:
1. Dana was bound with the white tape, then worked over pretty good. Johnny was also bound with the white tape. Not very well, but they were bound.
2. Dana was put in a chokehold, probably sitting on a hard chair. He died as a result, but remained sitting in place, suggesting that maybe his assailant did not even realize he had died.
3. Johnny was struck forcefully with something like a baseball bat, possibly AFTER realizing that Dana was dead. Assuming his assailant was right-handed, that means he was struck by someone standing in front of him. It's theoretically possible he was hit by Dana, but Dana was most likely choked from BEHIND, so... Johnny very likely lost consciousness immediately.
4. Johnny was stabbed in the voicebox to make sure he couldn't scream.
5. Johnny and Dana were moved from wherever they were assaulted to more or less the places they were found. They were "tied together" with electric cord (NO phone cord was used at all.)
5. Johnny was placed on the floor with his head on a cushion and stabbed in the side of the neck twice in the same wound, piercing his carotid artery. He bled out.
6. Sue came out of the girls bedroom, walked through the puddle of Johnny's blood, was shot in the chest with the pellet gun, then was battered with it. Then she was tied up and gagged. Then she was stabbed in the voicebox. Then she was stabbed in the chest with the butcher knife. Then, Johnny and Dana were knocked in the head a few times (never the faces) with the hammer.
7. This all implies several things: There was no original intention to kill ANYBODY. Dana was killed accidentally; Johnny had to be neutralized; their assailants tried to make the whole thing look like some kind of home invasion; Sue surprised them; they had to silence Sue; some or all of them left the scene taking they narrow blade and the pellet gun with them; someone stayed behind and stabbed Sue with the butcher knife and hit the two boys around the head (rather half-heartedly; or, perhaps, they weren't very strong) and oddly enough, did NOT remove the butcher knife or hammer from the cabin. But they DID cover Sue with TWO blankets from the girls bedroom. Not the boys. Just Sue.
8. These facts, plus Justin's "statements," suggest two things: A. Justin did the work with the butcher knife and hammer, probably AFTER the other assailants had left Cabin 28; and B. Think about it. It's terribly, terribly simple. True? Maybe not. But terribly simple.
9. What does the physical evidence tell us about what happened to Tina? Absolutely nothing at all. But it does suggest TWO things: Tina left Cabin 28 alive, probably more or less voluntarily, some time--we have NO idea when--between 10:00pm and 8:15 am. And that SHE covered Sue's dead body with the blankets before she left.
10. Remember, there is NO evidence of ANY kind AT ALL that ANY "outsiders" came into Cabin 28 that night.